Like I said before I have only watched WCW, WWE, AEW and TNA, so basing him on that.

Like I said in case of Edge and Chris Jericho, I am a big fan of wrestlers with long careers and lots of matches and feuds....Randy Orton is again one of them, but he's main evented for most part of his career, pretty good in stables, decent on mic, handy in stipulated matches, has the ability to work longer feuds...one of the all time best...

I would rank him at no. 10 in all time best wrestlers list.

You can rank him almost anywhere you want. He's pushing Undertaker for me although he was never the "draw" that Taker was. That isn't an insult though. I've never actually ranked these guys but enjoy commenting on the threads about it. I'd have him over Edge and Jericho. Long career and ALWAYS great in the ring. Safe smooth worker. Plenty of memorable feuds, won everything there is to win.

Fans really resisted him earlier and called him boring but I feel like the last 3-5 years people truly grew to appreciate his work. Very good during the pandemic times when the company needed him. Intense on the mic especially in his later years. Not the talker Cena was but did his job well enough when he was the big mean legend killer, the buzzcut voices years, or the younger ladies man version. One of the true GOAT villains in history.

if we did tiers he's probably tier 2 for me. Just below the Hogans and Cenas that could sell places out with just their name on the banners. Ranked higher than Sting and dare I say Savage though, or perhaps they're tier 2 as well. Ditto Bret, kinda in that area of ranking for me.

Yeah Tier 2 or Tier 3 would be perfect for him.

Tier 2 in terms of best overall, top 15
In ring top 5 imo