Forum
»
Carbrahs - Do you need to change transmission fluid?
- Results 1 to 20 of 20
-
Page 1 of 1
03-17-2024, 08:44 PM
-
#1
- FAPhaggot
- Hawaiian shirt hoarder
-
- FAPhaggot
- Hawaiian shirt hoarder
- Join Date: Nov 2015
- Posts: 24,226
- Rep Power: 185354
-
-
Carbrahs - Do you need to change transmission fluid?
First of all, let me start off by saying that I am car retarded and have no phucking idea how to work on them. In terms of knowledge, I am about on par with your average sloot.
The odometer on my 2013 Accord says I'm ready for an oil change (sure), changing filters (sure, and I know most mechanics will try and fukk me here), and a transmission fluid change. I called my redneck dad, and he said to not change transmission fluid in your cars. "I never have, it's a scam."
That doesn't smell right to me, so I figured I'd run it by carbrahs of misc. Is it a service I'm fine skipping?
The odometer on my 2013 Accord says I'm ready for an oil change (sure), changing filters (sure, and I know most mechanics will try and fukk me here), and a transmission fluid change. I called my redneck dad, and he said to not change transmission fluid in your cars. "I never have, it's a scam."
That doesn't smell right to me, so I figured I'd run it by carbrahs of misc. Is it a service I'm fine skipping?
FA Crew
Always Pick 1 Crew
"Experience is something you get right after you need it."
03-17-2024, 08:48 PM
-
#2
- Godfrd824
- Join Date: Oct 2008
- Location: DevilMayRage's Head, Rent Free
- Posts: 57,231
- Subscribers: 2
- Rep Power: 383063
-
-
It's not a scam. It needs to be done, more often if the car is a manual. Plus it's like $40 in ATF or oil. It's not like it's a $1500 thing.
When it comes your time to die, be not like those whose hearts are filled with the fear of death, so that when their time comes they weep and pray for a little more time to live their lives over again in a different way. Sing your death song and die like a hero going home.
03-17-2024, 08:53 PM
-
#3
- SaviorSelfJT
- clownslayer
-
- SaviorSelfJT
- clownslayer
- Join Date: Aug 2010
- Posts: 12,855
- Rep Power: 166618
-
-
You should do it if you want your car to last. Should be a really easy task on a 2013 accord
Best lifts:
Bench press: 315x5
Squat: 465x1
Strict press: 205x5
Deadlift: 405x13 (conv tap'n'go with straps)
03-17-2024, 08:54 PM
-
#4
You can drain and fill the same amount that came out. I think most don't have a fill anymore so you have to buy a special pump to put back in the fluid amount that came out. If you want your tranny to last, you should change the tran fluid, and if you drive or haul hard.
🤴Supreme Self Esteem Crew
5'5 110lb(MIL Spec) Asian Master Race Crew
Yacht/Boat Crew
03-17-2024, 08:59 PM
-
#5
- CrazySerbian
- Registered User
-
- CrazySerbian
- Registered User
- Join Date: Jun 2012
- Location: Canada
- Age: 35
- Posts: 5,522
- Rep Power: 27528
-
-
Not a scam.
But my dad had many cars last over 300k km without ever changing the fluid.
If you don't plan on reaching that kind of mileage I would say it's not necessary to change the fluid.
But my dad had many cars last over 300k km without ever changing the fluid.
If you don't plan on reaching that kind of mileage I would say it's not necessary to change the fluid.
Management Information Systems Crew
Canadian Crew
Serbian Crew
03-17-2024, 08:59 PM
-
#6
- BrianDaMan
- Registered User
-
- BrianDaMan
- Registered User
- Join Date: Jun 2011
- Posts: 22,168
- Rep Power: 383523
-
-
Long as your blinker fluid is topped up you're good to go bud
03-17-2024, 09:07 PM
-
#7
- MajorTendonitis
- Join Date: Jan 2016
- Location: East Kootenays BC
- Age: 65
- Height: 5'8"
- Weight: 241 lbs
- Posts: 41,954
- Subscribers: 8
- Rep Power: 714444
-
-
You can’t really do a very good job yourself , as there’s oil stuck in the torque converter and iyou need specialized equipment to flush it all properly. Plus you need to remove the oil pan to access the trannies filter.
I just paid them to do the tranny and was done with it . Transmissions are so much money nowadays,I think it’s worth changing it . When I don’t know ,as it depends on how hard the vehicle was used
I just paid them to do the tranny and was done with it . Transmissions are so much money nowadays,I think it’s worth changing it . When I don’t know ,as it depends on how hard the vehicle was used
Back with my Fam
03-17-2024, 09:38 PM
-
#8
- chrsschb
- Techno Brah
-
- chrsschb
- Techno Brah
- Join Date: Dec 2010
- Location: Georgia, United States
- Age: 41
- Posts: 12,342
- Rep Power: 83349
-
-
Originally Posted By Anachron⏩
This is referring to flushes where they pressurize the system and force new fluid in and old fluid out. Majority of people will just be doing a drain and fill, which depending on the vehicle has to be done more than once to get majority of the fluid changed.Here's the problem - if you have kept up with your fluid changes, then yes.
If you haven't, there's a ton of stories out there that replacing the fluid with fresh fluid will wash out all the deposits built up already, and make your tranny fail.
Of course, this only applies to automatics, if your car is manual, go ahead and change the fluid, it won't hurt.

If you haven't, there's a ton of stories out there that replacing the fluid with fresh fluid will wash out all the deposits built up already, and make your tranny fail.
Of course, this only applies to automatics, if your car is manual, go ahead and change the fluid, it won't hurt.

|| MFC || C7 Crew || Trance & Techno Crew ||
03-17-2024, 09:42 PM
-
#9
Originally Posted By MajorTendonitis⏩
No need to flush. Just drain and fill.You can’t really do a very good job yourself , as there’s oil stuck in the torque converter and iyou need specialized equipment to flush it all properly. Plus you need to remove the oil pan to access the trannies filter.
I just paid them to do the tranny and was done with it . Transmissions are so much money nowadays,I think it’s worth changing it . When I don’t know ,as it depends on how hard the vehicle was used
I just paid them to do the tranny and was done with it . Transmissions are so much money nowadays,I think it’s worth changing it . When I don’t know ,as it depends on how hard the vehicle was used
🤴Supreme Self Esteem Crew
5'5 110lb(MIL Spec) Asian Master Race Crew
Yacht/Boat Crew
03-17-2024, 09:42 PM
-
#10
- JeepBruh
- Platinum
-
- JeepBruh
- Platinum
- Join Date: Aug 2019
- Posts: 12,128
- Subscribers: 2
- Rep Power: 145296
-
-
Originally Posted By Anachron⏩
This. In order to avoid the above issues sometimes people will change out 1/3 - 1/2 of the fluid at a time if the car has high mileage. It's debatable what the best method is or if you should just ride it until it dies.Here's the problem - if you have kept up with your fluid changes, then yes.
If you haven't, there's a ton of stories out there that replacing the fluid with fresh fluid will wash out all the deposits built up already, and make your tranny fail.
Of course, this only applies to automatics, if your car is manual, go ahead and change the fluid, it won't hurt.

If you haven't, there's a ton of stories out there that replacing the fluid with fresh fluid will wash out all the deposits built up already, and make your tranny fail.
Of course, this only applies to automatics, if your car is manual, go ahead and change the fluid, it won't hurt.

Might want to go to a honda forum to hear the experiences from other people.
03-17-2024, 09:46 PM
-
#11
03-17-2024, 10:05 PM
-
#12
- FAPhaggot
- Hawaiian shirt hoarder
-
- FAPhaggot
- Hawaiian shirt hoarder
- Join Date: Nov 2015
- Posts: 24,226
- Rep Power: 185354
-
-
Ty for the responses, guys.
I'm at 98k miles right now. This car has been totalled by hail damage and paid out by insurance as such, but I'd like to keep it running because A. it doesn't have any onboard internet or chit that the govt could use to remotely shut me down (ded srs, Klaus Great Reset paranoia), and B. the used car market sucks a phat phuckin dikk right now.
I'm at 98k miles right now. This car has been totalled by hail damage and paid out by insurance as such, but I'd like to keep it running because A. it doesn't have any onboard internet or chit that the govt could use to remotely shut me down (ded srs, Klaus Great Reset paranoia), and B. the used car market sucks a phat phuckin dikk right now.
FA Crew
Always Pick 1 Crew
"Experience is something you get right after you need it."
03-17-2024, 10:34 PM
-
#13
- DolphinPilot
- Join Date: May 2015
- Posts: 49,469
- Rep Power: 367822
-
-
Like others said: don't do a flush, just a drain and fill. I did that a couple times on my car. The way I did it was:
-Remove drain plug and let the fluid drain (it won't all drain out. My car has like 7 or 8 quarts in the transmission but can only drain 3 quarts at a time)
-Fill with new fluid (check dipstick to make sure you're putting in the same amount, obviously)
-Drive around for a bit, making sure to go through all gears, including reverse
-Go back, lift the car up and drain & fill again. Repeat all this until you feel you have "replaced" all the fluid in the transmission.
However I've known others who have had good results just doing a single drain & fill maybe every 2 or 3 oil changes or so. My car is notorious for having auto transmission issues but I haven't had any issues yet with mine.
-Remove drain plug and let the fluid drain (it won't all drain out. My car has like 7 or 8 quarts in the transmission but can only drain 3 quarts at a time)
-Fill with new fluid (check dipstick to make sure you're putting in the same amount, obviously)
-Drive around for a bit, making sure to go through all gears, including reverse
-Go back, lift the car up and drain & fill again. Repeat all this until you feel you have "replaced" all the fluid in the transmission.
However I've known others who have had good results just doing a single drain & fill maybe every 2 or 3 oil changes or so. My car is notorious for having auto transmission issues but I haven't had any issues yet with mine.
03-17-2024, 10:48 PM
-
#14
- SaviorSelfJT
- clownslayer
-
- SaviorSelfJT
- clownslayer
- Join Date: Aug 2010
- Posts: 12,855
- Rep Power: 166618
-
-
Originally Posted By DolphinPilot⏩
I just did a single (single as in only one drain and fill per maintenance interval, not that I only did the operation once) drain and fill on my old Honda and never had any problems. Sucker lasted 340k miles and was still driving good when I got rid of itLike others said: don't do a flush, just a drain and fill. I did that a couple times on my car. The way I did it was:
-Remove drain plug and let the fluid drain (it won't all drain out. My car has like 7 or 8 quarts in the transmission but can only drain 3 quarts at a time)
-Fill with new fluid (check dipstick to make sure you're putting in the same amount, obviously)
-Drive around for a bit, making sure to go through all gears, including reverse
-Go back, lift the car up and drain & fill again. Repeat all this until you feel you have "replaced" all the fluid in the transmission.
However I've known others who have had good results just doing a single drain & fill maybe every 2 or 3 oil changes or so. My car is notorious for having auto transmission issues but I haven't had any issues yet with mine.
-Remove drain plug and let the fluid drain (it won't all drain out. My car has like 7 or 8 quarts in the transmission but can only drain 3 quarts at a time)
-Fill with new fluid (check dipstick to make sure you're putting in the same amount, obviously)
-Drive around for a bit, making sure to go through all gears, including reverse
-Go back, lift the car up and drain & fill again. Repeat all this until you feel you have "replaced" all the fluid in the transmission.
However I've known others who have had good results just doing a single drain & fill maybe every 2 or 3 oil changes or so. My car is notorious for having auto transmission issues but I haven't had any issues yet with mine.
Best lifts:
Bench press: 315x5
Squat: 465x1
Strict press: 205x5
Deadlift: 405x13 (conv tap'n'go with straps)
03-18-2024, 10:41 AM
-
#15
- crupiea
- Lifetime Member
-
- crupiea
- Lifetime Member
- Join Date: Aug 2006
- Location: San Diego, California, United States
- Posts: 42,878
- Rep Power: 232216
-
-
I have an older car with about 115k miles on it. Bought it used.
Took it to the shop recently for some radiator work and asked them about changing the radiator fluid.
They checked it and recommended not to do it as it didnt need it because it looked and smelled just fine. Thought it was pretty cool that a repair shop didnt even recommend it when they usually milk every last dollar they can from you.
Took it to the shop recently for some radiator work and asked them about changing the radiator fluid.
They checked it and recommended not to do it as it didnt need it because it looked and smelled just fine. Thought it was pretty cool that a repair shop didnt even recommend it when they usually milk every last dollar they can from you.
"To be a warrior is not a simple matter of wishing to be one. It is rather an endless struggle that will go on to the very last moment of our lives. Nobody is born a warrior, in exactly the same way that nobody is born an average man. We make ourselves into one or the other."-- Carlos Castaneda
03-18-2024, 10:46 AM
-
#16
- TappingTheZen
- Everettian
-
- TappingTheZen
- Everettian
- Join Date: Jan 2014
- Location: United Kingdom (Great Britain)
- Posts: 12,774
- Rep Power: 173816
-
-
You should absoloutly change it, just doesn't need doing that frequently. For most cars built in the last 20 years every 60-100k should be fine.
It's incredibly easy to do in an MT, but a bit of a ballache in an auto (and uses a LOT more transmission fluid)
I did a drain and fill with 10 ish litres of fluid on an e92 3 series with 130k on the clock about 5 years ago and it went fine. As above there are stories of changing it too late causing issues with debree and what not, but nearly all examples i've seen of this are when people attempt to flush the transmission, instead of just drain and fill. I'd say if you drain and fill it's 99.9% going to be fine and extend the life of the trannie.
At 97k miles i wouldn't even be remotely worried though, i'd just do it. I'd probably start questioning it if it had 150k+ miles.
What's also worth noting, that i haven't seen anyone else mentioning yet is:
1. Not sure how the trannie is setup on the honda, but on my BMW it was worth changing the filter & metatronic sleeve also while you're doing it.
2. Adaptions also needed resetting, the car 'adapts' to the age of the fluid, at least in the e92. These adaptions need to be reset to see a performance benefit from changing the fluid. I'm not sure if the same is true in your Honda but it's definately something worth investigating.
It's incredibly easy to do in an MT, but a bit of a ballache in an auto (and uses a LOT more transmission fluid)
I did a drain and fill with 10 ish litres of fluid on an e92 3 series with 130k on the clock about 5 years ago and it went fine. As above there are stories of changing it too late causing issues with debree and what not, but nearly all examples i've seen of this are when people attempt to flush the transmission, instead of just drain and fill. I'd say if you drain and fill it's 99.9% going to be fine and extend the life of the trannie.
At 97k miles i wouldn't even be remotely worried though, i'd just do it. I'd probably start questioning it if it had 150k+ miles.
What's also worth noting, that i haven't seen anyone else mentioning yet is:
1. Not sure how the trannie is setup on the honda, but on my BMW it was worth changing the filter & metatronic sleeve also while you're doing it.
2. Adaptions also needed resetting, the car 'adapts' to the age of the fluid, at least in the e92. These adaptions need to be reset to see a performance benefit from changing the fluid. I'm not sure if the same is true in your Honda but it's definately something worth investigating.
Originally Posted By crupiea⏩
This sounds alturistic but im not sure it is; it's the same thing here in UK. Many companies wont touch an auto transmission service, because it's actually not a great paid job considering the time it takes, and the risk involved of being blamed if the trannie then goes on to fail. There are much more efficient ways for them to make money than doing transmission fluid changes. Even BMW themselves refused to do mine, claiming its a 'lifetime fluid' (which really means '100k' since after 100k all cars are out of warranty and not their problem).I have an older car with about 115k miles on it. Bought it used.
Took it to the shop recently for some radiator work and asked them about changing the radiator fluid.
They checked it and recommended not to do it as it didnt need it because it looked and smelled just fine. Thought it was pretty cool that a repair shop didnt even recommend it when they usually milk every last dollar they can from you.
Took it to the shop recently for some radiator work and asked them about changing the radiator fluid.
They checked it and recommended not to do it as it didnt need it because it looked and smelled just fine. Thought it was pretty cool that a repair shop didnt even recommend it when they usually milk every last dollar they can from you.
03-18-2024, 10:47 AM
-
#17
03-18-2024, 10:51 AM
-
#18
- jimmybobjim
- Registered User
-
- jimmybobjim
- Registered User
- Join Date: Feb 2020
- Age: 56
- Posts: 2,764
- Rep Power: 20053
-
-
I did it on an older car with 160k miles, I don't think it had ever been changed before. I don't think I'll ever need to do it again. Don't think the car ran any smoother. I guess I'm glad it didn't break anything.
03-18-2024, 10:51 AM
-
#19
- wasp9166
- straight out da bronx
-
- wasp9166
- straight out da bronx
- Join Date: Nov 2008
- Location: NY
- Posts: 52,558
- Subscribers: 3
- Rep Power: 511065
-
-
If it's an at and the filter has never been done ,do it
Drain and refill every 60k otherwise
Never ,ever ,flush a trans
Certain cars have certain procedures
My 330i was a pia ,in every fkn way
Car has to be level ,have to let it come up to temp and circulate new fluid then top off
There's no fill ,or dipstick ,so you need a pump
This is usually European car bs
Japanese are simple drain and refill
Anyone saying trans fluid is lifetime is either a mechanic or a ja
Drain and refill every 60k otherwise
Never ,ever ,flush a trans
Certain cars have certain procedures
My 330i was a pia ,in every fkn way
Car has to be level ,have to let it come up to temp and circulate new fluid then top off
There's no fill ,or dipstick ,so you need a pump
This is usually European car bs
Japanese are simple drain and refill
Anyone saying trans fluid is lifetime is either a mechanic or a ja
03-18-2024, 12:56 PM
-
#20
- GuineaDago585
- Bert McGirt
-
- GuineaDago585
- Bert McGirt
- Join Date: Nov 2012
- Posts: 40,526
- Subscribers: 3
- Rep Power: 404055
-
-
Depends on the car. My car has “lifetime” transmission fluid guaranteed by the manufacturer. They’ve even sealed it so the fluid can’t replace by any mechanic.
Bookmarks
-
- Digg
-
- del.icio.us
-

- StumbleUpon
-
-
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts