Forum
»
Is MBA degrees an example of capitalism of cronyism?
03-06-2021, 12:57 PM
-
#31
- Atlastrength
- Banned
-
- Atlastrength
- Banned
- Join Date: Feb 2021
- Age: 56
- Posts: 1,011
- Rep Power: 0
-
-
Originally Posted By ScramFranklin⏩
While I completely understand that, you have to take into account much more factors than that. You have to look at age in which the degree was completed also. My friends father got his MBA at age 42 which bumped up his pay for a company he worked for for 15 years already. You also have to look at length of employment. And yes, as I stated Debt to Income ratio plays a bigger part. Who makes more money truly? The non college grad that makes 48k a year, has no debt, or the man who makes 100k a year with an MBA, but has 140k of debt of student loans, car loans, credit card debt, all with interest etc. Then compare their spending habits.Everything you listed is anecdotal.
https://dqydj.com/income-by-education/
High School Diploma Median Income: 33,000
Bachelors Degree Median Income: 60,000
Masters Degree Median Income: 77,220
Professional School Degree Median Income: 121,914
Doctorate Degree Median Income: 110,000
There is similar increases for the 1 percenters and average incomes of each group as well. A typical 1%er with only a high school diploma makes 182,000. Bachelors Degree 415,000
Please keep in mind that does not mean someone with no college education can't make 400,000. But data like this is much more useful than the anecdotes you listed.
But you are correct about debt being a factor that should be taken into account. Typically there is something called "return on investment" for pursuing higher education, ie, it pays for itself.
https://dqydj.com/income-by-education/
High School Diploma Median Income: 33,000
Bachelors Degree Median Income: 60,000
Masters Degree Median Income: 77,220
Professional School Degree Median Income: 121,914
Doctorate Degree Median Income: 110,000
There is similar increases for the 1 percenters and average incomes of each group as well. A typical 1%er with only a high school diploma makes 182,000. Bachelors Degree 415,000
Please keep in mind that does not mean someone with no college education can't make 400,000. But data like this is much more useful than the anecdotes you listed.
But you are correct about debt being a factor that should be taken into account. Typically there is something called "return on investment" for pursuing higher education, ie, it pays for itself.
I look at things from wealth perspective not just numerical. I make less than a lot of my friends but I have more money. I have no debt. I have less things. But I have much more monetary freedom and opportunity of wealth accrual. My risk is minimal. I lose my job? I am fine for over a year easily. Friends lose their job? They have maybe 2 months before chit hits the fan and they are crushed.
So although numerically on paper getting a degree is generally better, in this current market and economic climate/future climate, I don't think it is in the slightest. Job market, wage inflation vs. market inflation, COL, debt, etc create a formula of slavery. Spending years accruing debt while not making money compared to someone not accruing debt and having years of making money is more impactful.
Honestly though it comes down to an individual. The buddy I know that sold his landscaping business is a retard with money in terms of spending so that won't lend well long term. f
03-06-2021, 01:06 PM
-
#32
- ScramFranklin
- Registered User
-
- ScramFranklin
- Registered User
- Join Date: Jul 2017
- Age: 36
- Posts: 19,925
- Rep Power: 147928
-
-
Originally Posted By SillieBazzillie⏩
Full time top 25ish MBA graduates first job's base salary is a lot higher than that as well. Top 15ish even higher.You kids really think MBAs don’t matter? How many director+ jobs do you think are out there? Unless you’re internal or know someone, no MBA means no interview in the business world. And while obviously more prestigious schools mean more opportunities but even a state school with a good resume will get you an interview for most jobs.
And whoever said that they only knew 1 advanced degree dude making six figures must not know many people. Here in Maryland, an MBA +10 years of increasing responsibility gets you minimum of $100k in the corporate world. Hell I just had a dude with no MBA and only 6 years of experience list his salary demand at $105k. Corporate finance. Not an engineer or computer whatever.
And whoever said that they only knew 1 advanced degree dude making six figures must not know many people. Here in Maryland, an MBA +10 years of increasing responsibility gets you minimum of $100k in the corporate world. Hell I just had a dude with no MBA and only 6 years of experience list his salary demand at $105k. Corporate finance. Not an engineer or computer whatever.
Originally Posted By Atlastrength⏩
I agree with a lot of that. Although an MBA at 42 is a lot higher than what is typical.While I completely understand that, you have to take into account much more factors than that. You have to look at age in which the degree was completed also. My friends father got his MBA at age 42 which bumped up his pay for a company he worked for for 15 years already. You also have to look at length of employment. And yes, as I stated Debt to Income ratio plays a bigger part. Who makes more money truly? The non college grad that makes 48k a year, has no debt, or the man who makes 100k a year with an MBA, but has 140k of debt of student loans, car loans, credit card debt, all with interest etc. Then compare their spending habits.
I look at things from wealth perspective not just numerical. I make less than a lot of my friends but I have more money. I have no debt. I have less things. But I have much more monetary freedom and opportunity of wealth accrual. My risk is minimal. I lose my job? I am fine for over a year easily. Friends lose their job? They have maybe 2 months before chit hits the fan and they are crushed.
So although numerically on paper getting a degree is generally better, in this current market and economic climate/future climate, I don't think it is in the slightest. Job market, wage inflation vs. market inflation, COL, debt, etc create a formula of slavery. Spending years accruing debt while not making money compared to someone not accruing debt and having years of making money is more impactful.
Honestly though it comes down to an individual. The buddy I know that sold his landscaping business is a retard with money in terms of spending so that won't lend well long term. f
I look at things from wealth perspective not just numerical. I make less than a lot of my friends but I have more money. I have no debt. I have less things. But I have much more monetary freedom and opportunity of wealth accrual. My risk is minimal. I lose my job? I am fine for over a year easily. Friends lose their job? They have maybe 2 months before chit hits the fan and they are crushed.
So although numerically on paper getting a degree is generally better, in this current market and economic climate/future climate, I don't think it is in the slightest. Job market, wage inflation vs. market inflation, COL, debt, etc create a formula of slavery. Spending years accruing debt while not making money compared to someone not accruing debt and having years of making money is more impactful.
Honestly though it comes down to an individual. The buddy I know that sold his landscaping business is a retard with money in terms of spending so that won't lend well long term. f
Originally Posted By nothingshocking⏩
Mr. CFO baller... do you think you MBA has helped you reach the position you are at today? Did you do full time/part time/online? If you think it helped you, do you think the overall reputation/ranking of the MBA was a large part of that?MBA crew checking in
-Engineering Crew
-Self Improvement Crew
-Third Position Crew
-Keith Woods Crew
-Consolecel Crew
-Dr. Edward Dutton Crew
03-06-2021, 01:09 PM
-
#33
- atgbrahsrs
- ToningWasTooHarshForMe
-
- atgbrahsrs
- ToningWasTooHarshForMe
- Join Date: Jan 2015
- Posts: 16,298
- Rep Power: 67825
-
-
Originally Posted By SillieBazzillie⏩
Can you tell me where I said it doesn't matter? My OP states exactly the opposite. I just pointed out it introduces unfair mechanisms.You kids really think MBAs don’t matter? How many director+ jobs do you think are out there? Unless you’re internal or know someone, no MBA means no interview in the business world. And while obviously more prestigious schools mean more opportunities but even a state school with a good resume will get you an interview for most jobs.
And whoever said that they only knew 1 advanced degree dude making six figures must not know many people. Here in Maryland, an MBA +10 years of increasing responsibility gets you minimum of $100k in the corporate world. Hell I just had a dude with no MBA and only 6 years of experience list his salary demand at $105k. Corporate finance. Not an engineer or computer whatever.
And whoever said that they only knew 1 advanced degree dude making six figures must not know many people. Here in Maryland, an MBA +10 years of increasing responsibility gets you minimum of $100k in the corporate world. Hell I just had a dude with no MBA and only 6 years of experience list his salary demand at $105k. Corporate finance. Not an engineer or computer whatever.
Originally Posted By tunafishha⏩
Ignore, he doesn't understand statistics.Bullchit.
People who hold a degree make more money than those who don't.
Its as easy as 123.
People who hold a degree make more money than those who don't.
Its as easy as 123.
MBA from a top school helps. So does having a University degree.
Just people don't understand is that going to University for Burger Flipping Management ****s you your net worth, whilst going for other subjects heavily increases. (Barring business people who are outliers).
communist until you get rich
rightwing until financially secure
atheist until the plane starts falling
slootist until you get married
muslim after you get married
03-06-2021, 01:11 PM
-
#34
- Jasonw1178
- 5'3" 300lbs Fudge Rounds
-
- Jasonw1178
- 5'3" 300lbs Fudge Rounds
- Join Date: Dec 2012
- Posts: 44,104
- Rep Power: 271274
-
-
Originally Posted By SillieBazzillie⏩
Not often do I agree with Sillie but for once, right about something here. A degree isn't everything, but it helps. Is it really worth the 2 years of schooling and the expense of tuition vs. just learning in the fields I don't really know, but I wouldn't call it a waste.You kids really think MBAs don’t matter? How many director+ jobs do you think are out there? Unless you’re internal or know someone, no MBA means no interview in the business world. And while obviously more prestigious schools mean more opportunities but even a state school with a good resume will get you an interview for most jobs.
And whoever said that they only knew 1 advanced degree dude making six figures must not know many people. Here in Maryland, an MBA +10 years of increasing responsibility gets you minimum of $100k in the corporate world. Hell I just had a dude with no MBA and only 6 years of experience list his salary demand at $105k. Corporate finance. Not an engineer or computer whatever.
And whoever said that they only knew 1 advanced degree dude making six figures must not know many people. Here in Maryland, an MBA +10 years of increasing responsibility gets you minimum of $100k in the corporate world. Hell I just had a dude with no MBA and only 6 years of experience list his salary demand at $105k. Corporate finance. Not an engineer or computer whatever.
03-06-2021, 01:26 PM
-
#35
- tunafishha
- Registered CCP
-
- tunafishha
- Registered CCP
- Join Date: Nov 2014
- Posts: 29,114
- Rep Power: 27114
-
-
Originally Posted By atgbrahsrs⏩
Man shut ur bitch ass up.Ignore, he doesn't understand statistics.
MBA from a top school helps. So does having a University degree.
Just people don't understand is that going to University for Burger Flipping Management ****s you your net worth, whilst going for other subjects heavily increases. (Barring business people who are outliers).
MBA from a top school helps. So does having a University degree.
Just people don't understand is that going to University for Burger Flipping Management ****s you your net worth, whilst going for other subjects heavily increases. (Barring business people who are outliers).
I don't understand statistics? LOL.
The fkn audacity...
I ran a statistical analysis on top world athletes and extracted the WINNING FORMULA. You can run your own statistical analysis and extract jack chit from it.
I don't understand statistics.
MBA earns more money because they go back to school to get more skills in other areas. That's why they make more.
MBA teaches you "transferable" skills because the bulk of what they learned about their profession is through the Bachelors. MBA teaches you management skills etc.
https://www.collegeraptor.com/gettin...g-grad-school/
*Catholic Crew*
*Community College Master Race*
*5'5 Masterrace*
*Starbucks Crew*
*Buy high, sell low*
03-06-2021, 01:31 PM
-
#36
- ThatGuy950
- Floridayyy
-
- ThatGuy950
- Floridayyy
- Join Date: Sep 2007
- Location: Turks and Caicos Islands
- Posts: 15,255
- Rep Power: 171546
-
-
MBA from a t-25 program that IS PAID FOR BY YOUR COMPANY will only help, as long as the post-MBA commitment to them isn’t your left testi.
Top MBA programs have excellent networks and name recognition, but don’t do it if you’re dropping six figs out of your own money because that coin would, in 99% of cases, be better spent on property/investments. Only go when you don’t cut the check
Top MBA programs have excellent networks and name recognition, but don’t do it if you’re dropping six figs out of your own money because that coin would, in 99% of cases, be better spent on property/investments. Only go when you don’t cut the check
Coincel
Florida crew (lol at coldcels)
03-06-2021, 04:29 PM
-
#37
- imbeingcereal
- Registered User
-
- imbeingcereal
- Registered User
- Join Date: May 2009
- Age: 36
- Posts: 3,914
- Rep Power: 26058
-
-
Must be a bunch of slack-jawed tradies posting ITT if y'all unironically believe an M7 MBA won't help you earn a ton of money lmao. Yeah, most MBAs are garbage, but just lol at thinking an MBA from Columbia or Michigan isn't going to open doors to high-paying jobs for you.
03-07-2021, 01:26 AM
-
#38
- atgbrahsrs
- ToningWasTooHarshForMe
-
- atgbrahsrs
- ToningWasTooHarshForMe
- Join Date: Jan 2015
- Posts: 16,298
- Rep Power: 67825
-
-
Originally Posted By tunafishha⏩
I meant to say to you to ignore the guy you were responding to as he doesn't understand statistics that, in general, a university degree (a good one from a good school) and an MBA (from a good school) gives more life earnings.Man shut ur bitch ass up.
I don't understand statistics? LOL.
I don't understand statistics? LOL.
communist until you get rich
rightwing until financially secure
atheist until the plane starts falling
slootist until you get married
muslim after you get married
03-07-2021, 02:27 AM
-
#39
its 100% field dependent
my degree is in logistics and a masters in logistics is some top tier chit, people with masters in the field are so few and far between that you become a unicorn made of gold if you get it.
my degree is in logistics and a masters in logistics is some top tier chit, people with masters in the field are so few and far between that you become a unicorn made of gold if you get it.
Official LTC representative
03-07-2021, 03:27 AM
-
#40
- tunafishha
- Registered CCP
-
- tunafishha
- Registered CCP
- Join Date: Nov 2014
- Posts: 29,114
- Rep Power: 27114
-
-
Originally Posted By atgbrahsrs⏩
My bad.I meant to say to you to ignore the guy you were responding to as he doesn't understand statistics that, in general, a university degree (a good one from a good school) and an MBA (from a good school) gives more life earnings.
Yea I agree with you. A degree simply gives you more life earnings - in general.
That said, ops concern is the cost of the degree and job placement:
Average 4 year in state tuition is around 40-50k
https://educationdata.org/average-cost-of-college

Is degree worth it? I actually don't know. Lots of factors to consider here.
The unemployment rate for no degree is 12% while it is 6% for associates through bachelors.
The graph doesn't show if the rate has been adjusted for population size. So the actual unemployment rate for those who holds a degree may be much higher than 6%.
He may very well be on to something here.
*Catholic Crew*
*Community College Master Race*
*5'5 Masterrace*
*Starbucks Crew*
*Buy high, sell low*
03-07-2021, 04:02 AM
-
#41
03-07-2021, 04:25 AM
-
#42
- atgbrahsrs
- ToningWasTooHarshForMe
-
- atgbrahsrs
- ToningWasTooHarshForMe
- Join Date: Jan 2015
- Posts: 16,298
- Rep Power: 67825
-
-
Originally Posted By tunafishha⏩
Keep in mind that this graph also includes people with useless degrees. You can be a net loser from a degree if it is a fluff one.My bad.
The graph doesn't show if the rate has been adjusted for population size. So the actual unemployment rate for those who holds a degree may be much higher than 6%.
He may very well be on to something here.
The graph doesn't show if the rate has been adjusted for population size. So the actual unemployment rate for those who holds a degree may be much higher than 6%.
He may very well be on to something here.
Also, the OP is purely concerned with how it matches you to opportunities but the degree is behind a paywall.
communist until you get rich
rightwing until financially secure
atheist until the plane starts falling
slootist until you get married
muslim after you get married
03-07-2021, 04:29 AM
-
#43
- forthenoodz
- Registered User
-
- forthenoodz
- Registered User
- Join Date: Oct 2009
- Posts: 13,860
- Rep Power: 17632
-
-
totally agree that MBAs are pay to play
but most of the people who enter H/S/W are top tier from the start or already had connections/money/smarts etc.
but boggles my mind why i would drop 250k USD and 2 years of lost savings as a IBD assoc than go for a wharton MBA
but most of the people who enter H/S/W are top tier from the start or already had connections/money/smarts etc.
but boggles my mind why i would drop 250k USD and 2 years of lost savings as a IBD assoc than go for a wharton MBA
03-07-2021, 02:32 PM
-
#44
- tunafishha
- Registered CCP
-
- tunafishha
- Registered CCP
- Join Date: Nov 2014
- Posts: 29,114
- Rep Power: 27114
-
-
Originally Posted By Kiop⏩
You can only network once you have a job.only benefit
networking if
you are good in it
SRS
networking if
you are good in it
SRS
Networking as a college student does not work.
*Catholic Crew*
*Community College Master Race*
*5'5 Masterrace*
*Starbucks Crew*
*Buy high, sell low*
Bookmarks
-
- Digg
-
- del.icio.us
-

- StumbleUpon
-
-
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts